filtered by author

Author Archive: Mandy Walton

Sexual Orientation Discrimination; Case Law Examples

Leeds Pride took place in our glorious city this weekend; celebrating the diversity the LGBT community brings to our urban landscape.  Given the celebrations over the weekend, we thought it served as a timely reminder to look at discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation in the workplace.  

Sexual orientation is one of nine protected characteristics under the Equality Act 2010 and discrimination on those grounds is prohibited.  Discrimination can be:

  • Direct – because of their sexual orientation;
  • Indirect – a provision, criterion or practice that places those of a certain sexual orientation at a disadvantage;
  • Harassment – subjecting someone to harassment related to their sexual orientation; or
  • Victimisation – victimising someone because they have or intend to enforce their rights under the Equality Act 2010.

Here, we take a look at some case law examples to show you where employers (and service providers in some cases) have fallen foul of the law.

1. In Bull and another v Hall and another 2013, hotels owners were found to have discriminated against a homosexual couple in a civil partnership by refusing to allow them to stay in a room with a double bed.

2. In Lee v McArthur and Ashers Baking Company Ltd 2016, a Court in Northern Ireland found it was discriminatory for a bakery owner, who was Christian, to refuse to make a cake for a homosexual customer which includes the words “Support Gay Marriage”.

3. In Hubble v Brooks 2005, a pub owner refused to employ Mr Hubble (and his long-term partner) when he learned at interview that Mr Hubble was gay; despite Mr Hubble and his partner having the requisite experience required for the role.  This was, unsurprisingly, deemed direct discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation.

4. In Hegarty v The Edge (Soho) Ltd 2005, Hegarty, a heterosexual woman, was made redundant from her job in a mainly gay bar on the grounds that the owners wanted to “freshen up” the bar.  The owners subsequently hired male gay bar staff.  Hegarty was found to have been discriminated against on the grounds she was heterosexual.

5. In Ditton v C P Publishing Ltd 2006, having learnt during an interview that Mr Ditton was homosexual, his colleagues then subjected him to homophobic insults during his initial training when he commenced his employment.  Mr Ditton was dismissed after only 8 days of work and was successful in claiming direct discrimination and harassment on the grounds of his sexual orientation.

6. In English v Thomas Sanderson Ltd 2009, Mr English was subjected to homophobic insults during his employment even though he was not gay and his colleagues did not perceive him to be gay.  Mr English was successful in establishing he had been harassed on the grounds of his sexual orientation.

7. In Lisboa v Realpubs Ltd and others 2010, it was found that placing a gay employee under pressure to comply with his employer’s policy to make the pub less welcoming to gay customers was discrimination.  The employer in this case had taken various steps to re-brand the pub, including the implementation of a display board which stated, “this is not a gay pub”.

Here at SCE Solicitors, we are experts in helping businesses manage their employees.  If you have any queries about discrimination in the workplace, other staff issues or would like to discuss how we can be on hand to assist you with all your employment law needs, please contact me on 01133 50 40 30 or at

If you would like to be kept up to date with employment law and dispute resolution updates, please subscribe to our monthly newsletter.

SCE Solicitors is a boutique employment law and dispute resolution practice based in Leeds which advises clients nationwide.  Please note that the information in this blog is to provide information of general interest in a summary manner and should not be construed as individual legal advice. Readers should consult with SCE Solicitors or other professional counsel before acting on the information contained here.

Should shared parental leave pay reflect enhanced maternity pay?

Shared parental leave hasn’t had much press since its introduction in 2015. Most news-worthy stories simply commented upon the apparent lack of uptake, with new father’s not exercising their right to take such leave. One such report suggested that less than 1% of fathers had taken shared parental leave, speculating that the low uptake might be due to the fact that some employers paid enhanced maternity pay to mothers but shared parental leave pay was not comparable.

Read More

Reasonable adjustments for disabled job applicants

As lawyers, we know employment law can be a minefield for many employers out there.  The recruitment process is the start of any employment relationship and comes with its own obstacles as you must ensure any recruitment process is fair and objective.  Employers can expose themselves to risks of claims from job applicants if the recruitment process is discriminatory in any way.

Read More

Calendar Women and Men; Discrimination at Work

When writing this article, it would have been very easy for us to talk about ‘calendar girls’.  When most of us think about risqué calendars in the workplace, we think about scantily clad women.  But a browse through many of the calendar stores, most frequently filling the shopping centres each December, shows there are just as many male-equivalent calendars out there.  

We’re sure such calendars will have never been a feature in some work places but, for some employers, it’s custom and practice to see such images displayed.  Allowing such images to adorn the walls of your workplace is, undoubtedly, discriminatory but for those who are used to seeing such images, the thought probably never enters one’s mind.  We therefore bring you some food for thought of this infrequently discussed topic.

Read More

Worker Rate Changes 2017

Many of us will have been busy enjoying the long Easter break and the last thing that will be on anyone’s mind is whether payroll information relating to hourly rates has been submitted or processed to the relevant department. So we thought we would send everyone a reminder that as of the 1 April 2017 National Minimum Wage (NMW) and Living Wage rates changed. Please make sure that you have updated your payroll so that your workers get paid their legal entitlement. 

Read More

Easter Bank Holidays and Part Time Workers

Most businesses employ part time workers but some find calculating part time holiday entitlement difficult, especially when it comes to bank holidays.  As Easter approaches and many employees look forward to a long weekend, we decided to bring you some key advice on calculating holiday entitlement for your part time workers.

Read More

New Year’s Resolution Three; Review Your Personnel Files

Over the last few weeks we’ve been bringing you our recommended New Year’s resolutions to get your employment documentation in top shape.  So far, we’ve covered reviewing your employment contracts and your staff handbook, which are key documents in any employment relationship.  We hope you’ve found these useful to bring clarity and protection to your business. 

This week’s business New Year’s resolution to get your employment documentation in top shape is to review your personnel files.  All staff should have a personnel file but, in our experience, the contents of these vary from business to business.  So read our top tips below for what they should contain.

Read More

New Year’s Resolution Two; Review Your Staff Handbook

Last week we kicked off the New Year with our first recommended business New Year resolution to get your employment documentation in tip-top shape. If you missed our article on reviewing employment contracts, check it out here.

This week, we move on to staff handbooks. Do you have one in place for your employees? When was it reviewed? Is it up to date? Is it a short handbook containing some general rules or is a lengthier document covering your policies and procedures? Has it been issued to staff and do you have evidence staff have read and understood the contents? Here are our top tips for what a staff handbook should include.

Read More